Monday, March 16, 2009

Top 10 Projects To Revive

The great thing about open source is a project can never become extinct - there is always a chance of it being brought back to life either by the original authors who re-find their motivation, by new contributors who see the potential, or a mixture of both.



Here are the top 10 games, complete with cliches, I'd like to see return to the development scene and back on the road to completion.





1. Bloodmasters



homeproject

This gorgeous 3D top-down action game was released as open source last year after indie developer Pascal "CodeImp" vd Heiden found he'd lost motivation to continue with the project. It's a complete game with great graphics and needs a good C# developer to pick it up, port it to Mono, and help restore the community.





2. Project Citadel



homeproject

A very nice looking turn based strategy game set in World War II.



The game reached a playable state before it's development team ByteWare stopped playing the development game.





3. Windstille



homeproject

This project isn't technically dead - lead developer Grumbel occasionally bumps it with more concept work - but it's definitely in hibernation and progress is frustratingly slow.



Grumbel is actively seeking writers and developers so the prospects of reviving the project are quite good - no organizational work required.





4. Emilia Pinball



homeproject

Come on, who wouldn't love a great Free pinball game? Emilia Pinball is a fairly solid 3D pinball game that is playable, if a little "bare bones" in it's current form. A better table editor, some more tables, and a bit of love to the user interface and ball physics and this game would be a corker.



Hopefully one day a pinball wizard will resume improving this game and add another table or two as well as a few more features.





5. Labyrinth of Worlds



homeproject

Ultimate Underworld is my favourite ever game, and this is a project to create a new game based on it the 2nd instalment of the popular series. Since these days the world of Ultima is somewhat abandoned by it's foster parent company EA, I hoped projects like this and Underworld Adventures would have gained more support.





6. Boson



homeproject

The promising 3D RTS came a long way but never quite snowballed despite having nice graphics, original gameplay, and most of the hard work already done. I think the dependency on KDE libs was hurtful to attracting contributors.



It is original, playable, has a full set of units for two sides, nice graphics. It has everything going for it except momentum. Oh but to borrow a bit of enthusiasm from the Spring project, and Boson could spring back into life.





7. MyLink / MyNet



homesource

MyLink is inspired by the rather cool game UpLink. After encountering difficulties the author started from scratch with the name MyNet, but after hitting difficulties again (with motivation this time) the project got abandoned. The author is waiting for a new maintainer to step up to the plate. Until that happens, consider this project disconnected.





8. Civil



homeproject

Civil is a cross-platform, turn-based, networked strategy game, which allows players to take part in scenarios set in historical battle theatres. The U.S. Civil war was the primary focus before they started losing the battle and development stopped in 2005. Written purely in Python/Pygame, there should be plenty of people able to help out.



Battle simulations, how could that fail to be fun? When development dies, that's how!





9. Slickworm



homeproject

An innovative FPS where the terrain was deformable. It went through a few rewrites before the lead developer went silent. He was obviously talented and probably snapped up by a commercial company - a shame for the open source game community as it blows a big hole in the future for Slickworm; this potentially brilliant game looks like it'll never be more than a tech demo.





10. Battle for Antargis



homeproject

An original game that mixes elements of strategy and role play, this project enjoyed sustained development for several years and looked very promising before development tailed off as 2008 began. Hopefully somebody will pick things up again as this is one of those projects that counters the 'open source can only copy' popular criticism.



It had another original edge to it, it was probably the first significant Ruby game project, which probably doesn't help when it comes to attracting developers.



Honorable Mentions



Here's a few that I thought also had potential:



  • SilverTree RPG

    The lead developer of Battle for Wesnoth started to make an RPG! There was joyous celebrations and wide eyed expectation as SilverTree was unleashed on the public. Then he moved on to another project and the with it so went the development activity of the RPG.

  • Mars: Land of No Mercy

    A 2D mech strategy game that could be nice if development had no slowed to a near stand still. Every now and again something seems to happen that nearly equates to activity, so it didn't quite make the list.

  • GalaxyMage

    It once looked like a great new strategy game but the developers and the website went AWOL. Enthusiasts resumed development under the moniker Galaxy Mage Redux but it doesn't seem to be going anywhere other than the archives.

  • FreePop

    This was an attempt to recreate and improve upon the iconic Populous games of the early nineties. It never quite got to a playable state before the developer declared the project dead and moved on.

  • Legacy of Magic

    Another very promising war strategy game with very nice 3D graphics that never managed to emerge from abyss of alpha releases.

  • Fuzzy Adventure

    It came about at a time when the only platform games on Linux were SuperTux and XEvil. A quick burst of activity was never turned into long term development. I suspect that Fuzzy Adventure was just SuperTux with different graphics (gameplay was nearly identical) but that's never been confirmed.

  • Reaper3D

    A space shoot-em-up, this game was neary completed before it stalled.

  • OpenParsec

    This 3D space combat game was the darling of its time but very dated now. The developers declined to open source it for several years, and by the time they did the times, and with it the community, had long since moved on.


Another games you wished were still going?



Update: some more games that would be cool to revive:



  • Dark Oberon is an original 2D isometric RTS whose graphics are created by taking images of melded plasticine models.

  • Cspop, a Crystal Space populus-inspired game (svn, no homepage) previously mentioned (twice) on Free Gamer and announced on the happypenguin forums.

  • Zugspiel, a 3D train tycoon game (forum) which never quite made it after the author became inactive.

  • FreeTrain, a 2D isometric city & rail network building game. It needs an enthusiastic C# developer (contact me directly or post in the FreeGameDev Help Offered forum if you are interested).

18 comments:

  1. Great post charlie! I'd like to see Natural Born Keeper (remake of dungeon keeper) back in life. that game is awesome and it's a real shame it never got any sequel

    ReplyDelete
  2. You should pay attention to the OpenDungeons project which has made nice progress in the last few months.

    http://www.youtube.com/OpenDungeons

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'll take a look at Bloodmasters' source when I get home, seems nice.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'd like to see a new version of Bos Wars come out. I'm still looking for a really good OSS RTS game.

    http://www.boswars.org/

    Glest comes close, but I'd like to see a server browser and better support for multiplayer across multiple platforms. Perhaps Glest Advanced Engine will solve these issues?

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Bloodmasters port is possible. It's a lot of work though.

    ReplyDelete
  6. xBak, the new engine for running Betrayal at Krondor hasn't made releases for quite some time as well...

    ReplyDelete
  7. +1 For Slickworm, Battle for Antargis, and Silvertree

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey, good post :)
    Just wanted to let you know GalaxyMage Redux is not dead :)

    We are now on to our third project lead (me) - and we are working on the project, though not directly atm.
    Currently we are actually working on the 3d engine we will use for it, which is almost stable enough for GMR, so development should begin again in earnest here in a few weeks to a month :)

    Cheers, and keep up the good work :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. hellohter. check out the dark oberon's sourceforge site and screenshots. interesting for the graphics created in plasticine then captured and rendered into 3d models. loveable. and actually dead: last news dated november 2006 =(

    ReplyDelete
  10. http://egoboo.sourceforge.net/forum

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oops bad post. Good job on projects I didn't know had gone. Dam. Glad free gamer is keeping on top of these.

    ReplyDelete
  12. KQ! I think there was a sort of revival of it, but even it hasn't been updated for over a year.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Interesting stuff, that. Might take a look at some of 'em.

    ReplyDelete
  14. RG Pro Hockey, we definitely need some good free and open sourced sport game.

    ReplyDelete
  15. You should check two opensource Albion-related projects. Unfortunately, all of them are inactive - one from 2004 year and secound from 2006.

    http://www.albion2.de.vu/
    http://amberworld.sourceforge.net/ambrwrld.htm

    ReplyDelete
  16. another really good and already playable game that stalled because the developers were hired by a gamedev company is trigger-rallye.

    trigger.sf.net. code works and compiles and even though it is already a few years old there is absolutely no comparable driving game.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I wanna warn you there is a misprint in the url of Dark Oberon game at Update in Honorable Mentions paragraph. Correct url is http://dark-oberon.sourceforge.net, actual url is http://dark-oberson.sourceforge.net, keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete

lol, spam.